December 13, 2017

Potential CMC Name Change Findings

Over the past several days, I have done some "crowd sourcing" through Facebook in which I have created a few posts about the potential name change options for CMC and invited feedback about them.  This is in no way a scientific or statistically sound survey of opinions and thoughts.  At the same time, the feed back I have received has been helpful to me in refining my perspective.  Below is a summary of the perspectives I have received...

- Alliance: focused on the independence of the churches, un-engaging, aggressive, group opposed to something, politically charged, a break off group

-Network: feels business or technology related

- Rosedale: Churches located in Rosedale
"Rosedale," it seems means little to folks who have no awareness of the geographical reality of RBC, or RMM. In time though, if "Rosedale" does become part of the new name, the word will become a social identifier, and lose any geographical meaning. 

Question: how many churches are in Rosedale?  If there are no churches in Rosedale, I do not understand the reference to the word then.

I was surprised at the assumption of what a household name Rosedale is.

- Anabaptist: Against Baptist theology, People don't know what this means, 
Just my two cents, but I already think Anabaptist is overplayed. Mennonite might carry more baggage both among insiders and in wider culture, but it at least grounds the group in a kind of Anabaptism that likely represents most of the churches.

Rosedale Mennonite Alliance:
 I would guess that it was a group of Rosedale graduates that were working together to further or support certain Mennonite beliefs, values, callings, etc.

RAA does not trip off the tongue as an acronym (you know it would become an acronym).

The last alliance between Rosedale College and free Anabaptists 

Very conservative, charismatic and not into peace theology.

Conservative Mennonites trying to lose two stereotypes they don't want to have put on them: conservative, and Mennonite.

Rosedale Anabaptist Network: Prefer network to alliance

Rosedale Anabaptist Churches:
Rosedale Anabapist Churches feels like a brand to me (in a good way) because it identifies a more specific group of people without the older terms like Alliance. It feels a bit warmer as a name and includes the necessary Anabaptist definition. My favorite of them all.

Rosedale Network of Anabaptist Churches:
This option seems to be the "clunkiest" of them all. I also keep thinking about acronyms...RNAC, hmmmm.

I think this sounds "clunky" too. What if it was rearranged into "Rosedale Anabaptist Church Network?"

Not a fan. Seems, well--just too much. 

Overarching Reflections:
I have often thought a name change would be helpful for the entire Mennonite Church. Mennonite is too associated with Amish for outsiders, also more of an ethnic thing than something everyone is welcome to join. For me the name changes would be better at the church level, as in sign changes. I also feel like it should remain Mennonite at the Conference level. People joining our church membership should know exactly who we are and be taught the churches history. No one should be duped into thinking we are something we are not. From personal experience, those have been the people who become very decisive in our churches. They soon feel the church is their home and they expect the church to adapt to them. On another note, I feel like we have something to offer that other denominations do not. People are often surprised to learn that there are churches who teach peace and justice. A surprising number of people have felt homeless because of their peace positions. We should not lose our uniqueness, but we do need to learn how to share it better.

 I think just embrace the Mennonite name. We have a lot of good associated with our denomination. It creates a sense of heritage for me. Like I desire to serve and live a life that promotes a peace that only comes from God. To put the emphasis only on the Anabaptist portion seems to deny other parts of the Mennonite theology. It is okay to be unique. I feel like the denominations are in some ways a sampling of how God has gifted us - each unique, but all working to bring glory to God. I don’t think this is really what you are asking but thought I would throw my two cents out there.

I agree that we should embrace the Mennonite name. If the intention is to remain Mennonite, but change a name to be more welcoming, to me that is a bit hypocritical and possibly off putting to people who may come and then find out we're Mennonite. "Why is it not on your sign if that's who you are?" If people will not come because of the name Mennonite on a sign, it's not going to make them feel better when they find out. We are who we are, and we should not make it look otherwise. Be the same inside and out.

Still don't get the Rosedale reference. And if a person is worried that people recognize Mennonite but apply it in the wrong religious sect, then I can't quite understand how adding what seems to be a well known or famous town (I realize that's not what you said the hysteresis was)--how's that really any different. To me, when you have to explain things to people, now you have to explain why you changed the name. And as a newcomer, I'm just not really sure that's the story I want to hear. You know, we didn't think we were attracting enough people so we changed our name. Sigh. So many splinters.... and often, I think in moments like this churches are completely missing the boat on why folks aren't walking through the door. 

My point is, the Mennonite portion of the name is extremely important, IMO. The average Christian, let alone your average non-Christian, doesn't really understand what an Anabaptist is. I know what an Anabaptist church means, but I wouldn't have searched for an Anabaptist church on Google, know what I mean?  If anything, I would change the "conservative" portion of the conference name. I have no idea what Rosedale is, but "conservative" brings to mind flowered dresses, head scarves, and white tennis shoes. It brings to mind "I care more about what you wear than who you are" kind of vibes.  But I think the Mennonite part of the conference name is too important to toss out.

Important Questions Raised:
Who do you want to attract with this name? Or do you want the name to exhibit a purpose?

often, I think in moments like this churches are completely missing the boat on why folks aren't walking through the door. 

Potential CMC Name Change

Some of you are aware that the denomination that Pigeon River Mennonite Church (the congregation that I pastor) is a part of is considering a name change.  I have only been a part of the denomination for two years now, so I know little of the broader context and am continuing to work at better understanding the discussion.  What I gather is that this discussion happened about 10 years ago and resulted in no change because a suitable name was not found.  After a survey taken in the last two years and some input from a consultant, the discussion has resumed.

As I understand it, there are those who have concerns that "Conservative" does not represent us well in our current cultural context give the political overtones that are not necessarily consistent with who we are.  Additionally, while we are "conservative" in our theology, there are those that assume we are "conservative" in our dress; as in Amish, which we are not.

Likewise, there are concerns that the name "Mennonite" places barriers in people's minds who assume that Mennonite means Amish.  While we are not changing our theology, there are those who desire to be even more outreach focused and welcoming to those who do not have a Mennonite background.  Some, if not many in this camp believe that the name is the barrier and changing our name will make outreach more effective.   They believe that people will be more likely to walk through the front doors.

Given those realities, CMC leadership suggested a new name, "Rosedale Network."  After receiving feedback, they adapted the name to "Rosedale Network of Churches" and brought it to a vote at our summer ministers business meeting in 2017.  The name change failed (I believe by something like 2%).  The leadership of CMC has continued to work on this in preparation for the next ministers business meeting in February 2018.  They sent out the following e-mail inviting input and suggesting their rationale.

CMC Ministers:

In consultation with the RBC and RMM boards, the Executive Board has continued working on a name change for CMC.  The goal is to present a proposed name to the ministers in January, which would then be voted on at the business meeting in February. 

After prayerfully reflecting on the process of the past three years since the call for a name change came to the floor of the February 2015 business meeting, and after reviewing feedback from the vote in July on the name “Rosedale Network of Churches”, the Executive Board determined it would be best to move forward with a name that contains “Rosedale” and “Anabaptist” in it.  The options currently under consideration are: Rosedale Network of Anabaptist Churches, Rosedale Anabaptist Alliance, Rosedale Anabaptist Churches, and Rosedale Anabaptist Network.  

Rationale
  • While there has certainly been some pushback on including “Rosedale” in the name, there has been even more support for including it.  From the very beginning of the process to the present, whenever name suggestions have been solicited, “Rosedale” has been the most common word included in the suggestions received.
  • “Rosedale” carries a lot of name recognition in the larger Anabaptist world in the U.S. and abroad.  In fact, in many settings it seems we are already known as “Rosedale” more so than Conservative Mennonite Conference.  Rosedale has become a brand more than just a tiny spot in the cornfields of Ohio.  This is exemplified by RMM keeping “Rosedale” in their name after moving to Columbus, and naming their facility the Rosedale International Center.  Additionally Rosedale Business Group is a consortium of business people from various states whose focus is on doing business as missions around the world.  None of its members live or work in Rosedale.  Their name does not connect them to a location on the map, but rather to a brand.
  • Having “Rosedale” in the name contributes to a sense of unity and collaboration with Rosedale Bible College and Rosedale Mennonite Missions, something called for in Kanagy’s 2016 Mission & Identity Report resulting from a survey of 1,200+ people in CMC.
  • At the business meeting in July, nearly 2/3 of the voting ministers (64%) approved the name “Rosedale Network of Churches”.  Of those who didn’t approve, the most common objection expressed on the ballots was that the name did not include a theological marker.
  • Based on feedback received throughout this process, if a theological marker is to be included in the name, “Anabaptist” is preferable to “Mennonite”.  In fact, of 60 name suggestions submitted in a survey earlier in 2017, 33 of them contained the term “Anabaptist” while only 14 contained “Mennonite”.
  • Since the terms “Anabaptist” and “Mennonite” both require some explanation for those we are trying to reach who are unfamiliar with our church history or those who have preconceived notions of who we are, it seems advantageous to be named after a movement rather than a person.
  • Using a term like “network”, “network of churches”, “churches” or “alliance” helps keep the emphasis on the local church and not the organization.  It’s important to reflect in the name that the organization exists for the benefit of the local churches, not the local churches for the benefit of the organization.
  
I welcome your responses/feedback to this rationale in the comments.