Of Kings and Prophets: the
fall of Saul
April 19, 2015
BMC- I Samuel 15:10-23 (8:1-10:27, 13:7-14, 14:24-46)
Through the Bible in a Year
Introduction: The First Accident
I think
that it is safe to say that most of us in this room this morning have gone
through a particular American rite of passage.
It is an achievement which became for many of us our first real sense of
independence from our parents. Because
often upon reaching this milestone, we gain a new level of responsibility and
mobility that this achievement affords us.
And we feel this sense of freedom even though in reality we are still
typically very dependent on our parents.
I, of course, am talking about obtaining one’s driver’s license.
Now I’ll be honest with you, I did
not pass my driver’s test the first time.
I passed the book part and the maneuverability with no problem. But unfortunately, I did not pass the in town
driving part of it on the first try.
Perhaps I was too nervous.
Perhaps I didn’t practice enough.
I’m not sure the cause; but I went in on New Year’s Eve to retake the
driving portion of the test. And to be
honest, I went in knowing full well that there was no way on God’s green earth
that the woman instructing me was going to pass me that morning. After all I thought, “Who in their right mind
would give a new driver’s license to a sixteen year old male on New Year’s
Eve?”
But by the grace of God or a lack
of nerves that day since I didn’t expect to pass anyway, I did pass and I received
my driver’s license that morning some 22 years ago now. And overall, I was a pretty responsible
driver starting out. I went a full six
months without an accident. I know this
because at the time, the statistics suggested that as a male teenager, I should
have my first accident within the first six months of getting behind the
wheel. And for some reason, my dad made
a point of taking me in to have coffee with his insurance agent when I passed
that milestone and remained accident free.
But unfortunately, my streak came to an end the following November.
I was participating in a regional
orchestra with a couple of other students from my area. Being one of the first drivers in my class, I
drove as we carpooled up to Toledo on a Friday for the representatives in the
orchestra to practice together. Following
the practice, one of my friends was staying in Bowling Green for the night with
a friend of hers. So I drove her to BG
and then made my way to my Grandmother’s house in Wellington to spend the
night. At the time, this seemed like it
made sense; but looking back I realize that it was a longer drive than I had thought
it would be.
I made it to my Grandmother’s house
that evening a little later than expected but without incident. We visited a bit and then I went to bed. I had to get up pretty early the next morning
to get back to BG to pick up my friend and then to get back up to Toledo for
another rehearsal before the concert late Saturday afternoon.
Unfortunately, I was running a
little behind that morning and that paired with the heavy rain made for a bad
combination as I tried to make up a little time. Perhaps what led to my trouble that day was a
bit of what happened to Saul in our story for this morning as well. But before we get to that, let’s first take a
step back and look at the bigger picture here.
The Call of Saul (I Sam 8:1-10:27)
In our reading through the Bible
chronologically this year, we have made a distinctive turn in the trajectory of
the nation of Israel. For hundreds of
years after entering and beginning the conquest of the Promised Land, Israel
was led and protected by judges. Even
our reflections on Ruth last week fell within the time frame of the judges; but
as Samuel, the last of the judges was aging; the people called for a king.
Samuel was hurt and disappointed by this
request, but God reassured him that it was not Samuel that the people were
rejecting. The people were rejecting God
as their king, yet God instructed Samuel how he should proceed. First Samuel warned the people about what
having a king would mean. A king will
claim your sons for his army. A king
will take your daughters to be his perfumers, cooks and bakers. And a king will take from your produce and
livestock, but the people persisted and God consented.
And so it was that one day the donkeys
of a Benjamite named Kish were lost.
Kish sent his son, Saul, out to find the donkeys along with one of his
servants. The two searched for quite
some time but were unable to find the donkeys.
As they were considering heading back home, the servant suggested that
they go to the man of God for direction.
Now God had instructed Samuel the day
before that God would send a Benjamite to Samuel the next day. Samuel was told to anoint the man that God
sent to be king over Israel and so when Samuel saw Saul, he welcomed him and
assured him that his donkeys were fine.
Samuel invited Saul to dinner and to spend the night and Saul did so.
In the morning, Samuel anointed Saul
with oil and told him of several signs to come.
He told Saul of two men that he would meet at Rachel’s tomb, of three
men going up to worship at Bethel, and of a procession of prophets. Each of these signs was fulfilled and Saul
was appointed king before all the people.
He soon had success over the Ammonites and was reaffirmed king of the
whole nation. With that, Samuel had
given the call to Saul and stepped aside; yet not long after the call of Saul
came the fall of Saul.
The Fall of Saul (I Sam 13:7-14)
Sometime later, the Philistines assembled to attack
Israel. As Saul waited with his men to
attack the Philistines, his men were quaking with fear. He waited for seven days for Samuel to
arrive; but when he did not come, Saul’s men began to scatter. So Saul took the bull by the horns as it were
and offered the burnt offering himself.
He did what he thought was right given the circumstances.
Yet just as Saul finished making the offering,
Samuel arrived. Saul went out to greet
him, but Samuel asked what it was that he had done. Saul replied, “When I saw
that the men were scattering, and that you did not come at the set time, and
that the Philistines were assembling at Mikmash, I thought, ‘Now the
Philistines will come down against me at Gilgal, and I have not sought the Lord’s favor.’ So I felt compelled to offer the burnt offering.”
“You have done a foolish thing,”
Samuel said. “You have not kept the command the Lord your God
gave you; if you had, he would have established your kingdom over Israel for
all time. But now your kingdom will not endure; the Lord has sought out a man after his own heart and appointed him ruler of
his people, because you have not kept the Lord’s command.”
This was the beginning of the end
for Saul. It was the beginning of the
fall of Saul. It would seem that Saul
thought that he was doing the right thing.
He was trying to seek the Lord’s favor by offering the sacrifice before
going to battle. Yet when we read this
more closely, we see that in reality he probably did this more out of fear that
the men were leaving than an attempt to be faithful. And Saul performed this offering when he was
not one who was authorized to do such things.
He took control of the situation rather than depending on God.
The Gall of Saul (I Sam 14:24-46)
We see the dynamic of Saul acting out of
fear of the people again with the gall of Saul to make a foolish oath. Jonathan, Saul’s son, was away attacking the
Philistines when Saul put the Israelites under a foolish oath. “Cursed be anyone who eats food before evening comes, before I have
avenged myself on my enemies!” So none of the troops tasted food,” that is
except for Jonathan.
Jonathan, Saul’s son, had
not heard the oath. So when Saul’s army entered
the woods and found honey, no one took any except for Jonathan. Later when Saul inquired for direction about
continuing the attack, the Lord did not answer.
And Saul knew that someone had broken their oath. He cast lots and determined that it was
Jonathan who had broken the oath. At
that, Jonathan confessed to what he had done.
Saul had every
intention of following through on his oath and killing his own son Jonathan for
what he had done. Yet it was the men who
interceded on Jonathan’s behalf and convinced Saul that he should not kill
Jonathan. Now I’m not suggesting that
Saul should have killed Jonathan. Saul
should not have had the gall to make that foolish oath in the first place. But once the oath was made, Saul once again
seemed to fear his men, who convinced him not to kill Jonathan, over this oath
to God.
Pitfall of Saul
Perhaps it was this fear of men over the fear of God that
was the pitfall of Saul. We see that as
Saul prepared to battle the Amalekites, Samuel brought Saul a message. “’I will punish the Amalekites for what they did to Israel when they
waylaid them as they came up from Egypt. Now go, attack
the Amalekites and totally destroy all that belongs to them. Do not spare them;
put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and
donkeys.’”
The
instructions here were clear. Saul was
to destroy everything. And to be honest,
I struggle with these instructions. They
don’t make sense to me; and yet within this, we see another instance in which
God gave instructions and Saul failed to fulfill them. It reminds me of when Moses was instructed to
speak to the rock, but instead he struck it and then he was unable to enter the
Promised Land as a result.
Because
when Saul did attack the Amalekites, he killed everyone except, he took their king, Agag, alive. They also spared “the best of the sheep and
cattle, the fat calves and lambs” rather than destroying everything. And after this God regretted that he had made
Saul king because he did not carry out God’s instructions. It would seem that this was the Pitfall of
Saul.
Samuel
went to Saul and when he arrived, Saul said, “The Lord bless you! I have carried out the Lord’s
instructions.” But Samuel said, “What then is this
bleating of sheep in my ears? What is this lowing of cattle that I hear?”
“Saul answered, “The soldiers
brought them from the Amalekites; they spared the best of the sheep and cattle
to sacrifice to the Lord your God, but we totally
destroyed the rest.” Saul seemed to think that he has made the right choice in
these circumstances. He seemed to say
that he did this in an effort to honor God.
But Samuel replied to Saul. “‘Enough! Let me tell you what the Lord said to me last night.’ ‘Tell me,’ Saul replied.
Samuel said, “Although you were
once small in your own eyes [Samuel names Saul’s insecurities here], did you
not become the head of the tribes of Israel? The Lord anointed
you king over Israel. And he sent you on a mission,
saying, ‘Go and completely destroy those wicked people, the Amalekites; wage
war against them until you have wiped them out.’ Why
did you not obey the Lord? Why did you pounce on the
plunder and do evil in the eyes of the Lord?”
“But I did obey
the Lord,” Saul said. “I went on the mission the Lord assigned me. I completely destroyed the Amalekites and brought back
Agag their king. The soldiers took sheep and cattle
from the plunder, the best of what was devoted to God, in order to sacrifice
them to the Lord your God at Gilgal.” Now I
don’t know about you, but as I read this, it sounds a bit like some of the conversations
I have with my kids. There are times in
which they have clearly not followed my instructions and yet they try to claim
that they have or that what they have done was better than what I asked of
them.
“But Samuel replied:
“Does the Lord delight in
burnt offerings and sacrifices
as
much as in obeying the Lord?
To obey is better than sacrifice,
and
to heed is better than the fat of rams.
For rebellion is like the sin of divination,
and
arrogance like the evil of idolatry.
Because you have rejected the word of the Lord,
he
has rejected you as king.”
“Then Saul said to
Samuel, “I have sinned. I violated the Lord’s command
and your instructions. I was afraid of the men and so I gave in to them.”
Ah, the truth comes out. Saul feared the
men more than he feared God. That is why
he acted the way that he did. It would
seem that this was his pitfall.
Following the Accident
So as we
consider the fall of Saul, it seems to me that we have a few things going on
here that contribute to his fall. In the
best case scenario, Saul was simply trying to do the best that he could given
his circumstances. He was making his
choices with the intention of following God but got his priorities out of whack
and made some misguided choices.
I think that’s
what happened with me in my first accident.
I was running behind and without realizing it, I placed being on time as
a higher priority than being safe. As I
said, not only was I running behind that morning, but also the rain was coming
down pretty heavy. I tried to make up
some time by going a little faster than I should have. And as I was coming down a little hill, my
car began to hydroplane. As most of you
know that is when your car is riding on the water, rather than the road and it
means that you have little or no control.
Thankfully, no
one was coming the other direction or following closely behind me when I
drifted to the other side of the road and connected with the guard rail. I slid backwards along it for a little ways
before crossing backward to the other side of the road and coming to a
stop. When all was said and done, I was
fine not having sustained any injuries; but three of the four sides of my car
were in bad shape and ultimately the car was totaled. I had thought at the time that I was making
good decisions, but in reality had my priorities out of whack.
Conclusion: Obey God rather than Men
It seems to me that this would be
the best case scenario: Saul made honest yet foolish choices. But it also seems to me that there is likely
something much deeper going on here with the fall of Saul. It seems to me that he had a much deeper pitfall
than foolishness. We see in Saul his
insecurities in his hiding from his coronation.
We see his tendency to take control of a situation rather than waiting
on God in his choice to offer the sacrifice before Samuel arrived. But perhaps worst of all, we see his fear of
men that outweighed his fear of God.
Saul performed that sacrifice
preemptively because the men were fearful and Saul feared losing the men. Saul did not carry out his oath to God to
kill Jonathan, a foolish oath that he never should have made, because he listened
to men. And Saul brought back the best
of the livestock from the victory of the Amalekites rather than killing it all
as he had been instructed to because he feared the men.
And I wonder how often this may be
true of us as well. How often do we
choose to take control of a situation rather than wait on God’s will and God’s
timing? How often do we act more out of
the fear of men rather than the fear of God?
How often do we allow our own insecurities guide our poor decisions?
In Acts 5 we read of Peter and the
apostles before the Sanhedrin. Peter and
John had been telling people about Jesus and the Sanhedrin wanted them to
stop. They instructed the apostles to
stop teaching about Jesus. But they had
continued and now they were being told again to stop doing so. Peter replied to these instructions, “We must
obey God rather than any human authority.”
They chose to obey God rather than to obey men.
There was much that contributed to
the fall of Saul. But it seems to me
that his own insecurities paired with his fear of men were his significant
pitfalls. As we go from here today, may
we follow the example of the apostles and obey God’s authority rthan than
stumble into the pitfall of Saul.
Amen.