Article 24: The Reign of God – to experience and extend
May 29, 2011
BMC- Mark 1:9-15 & Revelation 21:1-4
Introduction: Set-up
This morning, we come to Article 24: The Reign of God, our last article in the Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective. As I reflected upon this article and the whole of this series, I couldn’t help but note that while the sequence and date of these topics was set over a year ago; several of them have been very timely with current world or congregational events. This is both an incredible blessing and a discernment challenge because it is all the more obvious that God has something to say to us and all the more important to work at separating my own words from God’s words.
It also seems to me that a number of these articles invite us to consider scripture and our relationship with God in new ways or in ways that are different from the typical American Christian framework for faith. In those circumstances, I find myself deeply valuing our Anabaptist emphasis on community for discernment and feel more drawn to dialogue in which we learn together than a monologue declaring what truth is for all.
That’s where I find myself with this article as well given that often times our consideration of the reign of God and the final consummation of time focus on fear and judgment. Yet I believe that our article and its 3 commentaries should invite us to focus more on love, grace, and freewill in how we live out our faith.
Now and Then
For instance, in our modern understanding of the Reign of God, we tend to focus on the Kingdom’s future reality, of the return of Christ and God’s final consummation. And yet our article is clear, there’s a now and then quality of the Reign of God.
It begins by saying that “We place our hope in the reign of God and in its fulfillment in the day when Christ our ascended Lord will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead.” It goes on to name our expectation of the new heaven and the new earth that our Revelation 21:1-4 passage for this morning describes. In these ways, it declares that future reality.
And yet while the Reign of God is not fully present yet, it has begun the process of breaking into our present world both through acts of God and through the acts of believers who live out the principles of God's Reign even today. This is the emphasis of commentary #1 at the end of the article and of the article itself.
It states that, “We believe that the church is called to live now according to the model of the future reign of God. Thus, we are given a foretaste of the kingdom that God will one day establish in full.” It goes on to say, ”We affirm that, in Jesus' ministry, death, and resurrection, the time of fulfillment has begun.”
After all as Jesus himself suggests in a number of places including Mark 1:9-15 that with the coming of Jesus, the Kingdom of God has come near. Thus in living out the way of Christ, we are living into the Reign of God today, bringing the Kingdom near.
It seems to me that this serves as an important corrective for recent claims that Christ would return on May 21, 2011 because the Reign of God is not just about a future date or event. It is also about living into it to the best of our abilities even today.
And we should remember as commentary #3 notes that Jesus himself said in Matthew 24:36, that not even the angels nor the Son himself know the day or the hour of his return. If Christ doesn't know the day, then certainly none of us do either and it seems contradictory to suggest that God hid that information within the scriptures for us to find or decode all these years later.
While we are always to be ready for Christ's return, it seems to me that declaring a date for it is harmful. Not only is declaring a date ultimately incorrect and thus destructive to the credibility of our witness, but also it lends itself toward people acting irresponsibly or believing that they no longer need to live out their faith. The Reign of God becomes only a future reality which we bide our time waiting for.
Judgment and Grace
Thus the Reign of God is both Now and Then. Yet when we reflect on the coming Reign of God, one of the most significant components of this article are the questions that arise about the realities of judgment and grace. You may have noticed that in our 24 articles, we do not have an article that addresses grace directly as some confessions do. In fact, I think that it’s fair to say that while we do believe in grace, we do not tend to talk about it much.
I became aware of this a few years ago when my father-in-law was preparing a sermon for his previous congregation on the topic of grace and predestination. It was turning out to be a much more technical sermon than he typically does and he was telling me about his preparation for it. Being United Methodist, at one point he stopped and asked what Mennonites believe about grace. To be honest, I had to stop and think about it.
After a bit, I shared that we believe in God’s grace; but in the process I realized that we typically don’t talk much about it. I also wasn’t sure if my answer came more from my own upbringing or from my Mennonite education or experience.
Given that we do believe in God’s grace, why don’t we talk more about it? This may be for a number of reasons one of which being our focus on the importance of living out our faith. We believe that we are saved by grace but also that faith without works is dead as James reminds us. All too often in history, the focus has been so heavy on salvation through God’s grace to the exclusion of doing any works, that Christians have neglected to live out their faith and even lived in ways that were counter to faith. After all, it was Christians who claimed to be saved by grace that were torturing and killing the Anabaptist martyrs.
Another reason for not emphasizing grace in our tradition may be a concern about promoting cheap grace in the process. Bonheoffer addresses this in his writings. When all that we talk about is the unending grace of God that freely forgives us for all of our wrongs and our shortcomings, we can have a tendency to lose sight of the price that was paid for that grace. The grace itself is free to us, but it was costly to God.
For that grace to be established, God had to send His Son into the world. In the process, Jesus suffered and died on the cross. He was dead in the tomb before rising from the dead on the third day. God’s grace is offered freely to us, yet it wasn’t cheap and it shouldn’t be treated as such.
In any case, we believe in God’s grace; and yet when we come to the realities of God’s judgment, we may feel uncomfortable as commentary #2 notes. We may find ourselves still asking deeper questions like that of whether or not we are predestined to be saved and whether or not there is eternal security in our salvation. These are complex questions that tend to result in deeply theological responses.
When we consider the question of predestination, whether God determined before creation who would be saved and who would not; it seems to me that the faithful Anabaptist response is to say that God has always known the outcome of whom would be saved in the end but that God did not predetermine it for us. That is to say that if we believe the nature of God’s love for us and we believe in the importance of freewill for that love to be real, God had to give us the chance to choose for ourselves whether or not we would love God in return and thereby accept God’s salvation.
Without that free will, without that choice to choose God or not to choose God, God’s love is a false and imperfect love. Furthermore without that opportunity to choose, God’s call upon us to share the depth of God’s love with others, to invite others to a saving relationship with Jesus Christ, is a call for us to lie to the world about who God is and the depth of God’s love for everyone.
Likewise, one might ask if we believe in a once saved always saved understanding of the gospel, if once accepting Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior we can ever lose that state of salvation or remove ourselves from our eternal place with God. Once again it seems that a faithful Anabaptist perspective on this is that once we have accepted Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, we have security that God will fulfill God’s end of that covenant with us but that our free will remains, that we may choose to turn our backs on God.
Without the ongoing free will to change out minds, to choose a different course, God’s love becomes selfish and controlling and God’s grace becomes cheap. Moreover if we are never able to remove ourselves from God’s love or to reject it, then we do not need to worry about living a life of faithfulness before our God.
Yet Hebrews 10:26-27 tells us that “If we deliberately keep on sinning after we have received the knowledge of the truth, no sacrifice for sins is left, but only a fearful expectation of judgment and of raging fire that will consume the enemies of God.” Thus our choices about how we live our lives following the acceptance of our salvation truly matter. We are not to continue to live a life of deliberate sin in which we turn our backs on God and reject the sacrifice of salvation that God offers us because God will not force God’s love on us and Christ’s ultimate sacrifice is the only means to salvation that God gives us.
And if we can never choose to renege on our commitment to God, than we have no reason to commit to the difficult life of discipleship. Without that freedom, we can do whatever we want because we are covered by the grace of God. In essence if we no longer can choose to reject God, we can then do as we please in life with no regard for the ways of God. Thus in effect we hold God captive by His own covenant, unable to do anything in response but to slap our wrists for our wrongs.
Yet Hebrews 6:4-6 tells us “For it is impossible to restore again to repentance those who have been once enlightened, and have tasted the heavenly gift, and have shared in the Holy Spirit, and have tasted the goodness of the word of God and the powers of the age to come, and then have fallen away, since on their own they are crucifying again the Son of God and are holding him up to contempt.” It seems to me that this verse tells us that we are able to give up our salvation, to turn our backs on God.
But I don’t think that it is that God removes salvation from us rather that we choose to remove ourselves from God, which is why it is then impossible to restore us to faith. It is not that God would not accept us back, but that we have chosen not to accept God after all and God will not force God’s self on anyone. Moreover, if one has seen all that God has to offer in accepting God and still chosen to go one’s own way, there is little that God can do to bring one back to salvation. God has already done all that God can do and they have already experienced all that God has to offer and they have still rejected God.
Heaven and Hell
All this brings us to a final point of tension for many of us in our faith. Assuming then that we all can agree that God loves us and that it is out of love that God acts, the question may become, “What do we mean by love?” Certainly, there is a lot that can be said here and we can’t cover it all today so maybe it is more important to think for a moment what love is not.
A new TV series called Harry’s Law came out this year on NBC. Harriet, who goes by Harry, was a patent lawyer but moves on to open a law practice in a shoe store. It’s my mother-in-law’s dream come true…a legal drama with great shoes. This shoe store isn’t in the best part of town so she begins to represent some interesting clients and ends up in some interesting situations.
In one episode, she is faced with a husband who is locking his wife in the basement. As she comes to know the husband, she learns that he doesn’t see anything wrong with what he is doing because he loves her and is showing that love by making her stay. She also learns that he is a war veteran who has developed mental illness from what he experienced while serving in the military. In the end, the wife comes to understand the situation and the husband agrees to seek professional help.
I think that it is safe to say, that none of us would accept a definition of love that includes holding someone prisoner. Many of us might also wonder about the possibility of mental illness playing a role in these circumstances as it did in this particular show. For love to be present and real in a relationship it must be given not taken and it must be reciprocal.
So it is with God, the one who knows true love better than anyone one of us ever will or ever could imagine. God loves us and desires to have a real relationship of love with us. For this to happen, God must give us the choice to love God back. If God does not give us the choice, the love is not real. And if the love is forced rather than reciprocal, the love is false.
This applies to the Reign of God in so many ways, but it seems to me that one of the biggest stumbling blocks about this related to our article for today connects to questions around heaven and hell. Our article is pretty direct about the reality of heaven and hell and it seems to me that as I read scripture, the Bible is pretty clear about it as well.
And yet, there are faithful Christians reading the same scriptures that I read who do not believe that hell is real. For some, this is mediated by redefining what exactly hell is and breaking from our stereotypical assumptions. Given that none of us know exactly what hell is like, I think there is room for humility on our parts to consider these ideas and at least honor them if not fully embrace them.
For others, the existence of hell in any form is unacceptable. This is for a variety of reasons. The most common reason I hear is the question of “How can a truly loving God send anyone to hell?” That’s a valid question and to be honest there’s a part of me that wishes that hell, however we define it, didn’t exist; and yet as I read the scriptures, I am not able to see a Biblical worldview without it. I’m open to discussing it and to the possibility that I may be corrected by the community of discernment; but as I read scripture, I am unable to see a way around it.
Beyond the many scriptural references which in one way or another point toward there being a hell, I don’t see how we can call God truly loving without having some form of hell in the universe. Now to some that sounds like an oxymoron to say that God’s love requires a hell in order to be real, but for me it goes back to the example I shared with you a moment ago.
Some will say that a truly loving God will not send anyone to hell. I think that this is true but that the flip side of it is true as well. A truly loving God will not force anyone to come to heaven either. As I see it, God is not forcing people to go to heaven or to hell, but rather God is allowing them to choose that path. God is looking for real love, which means that it must be chosen and it must be reciprocal.
If God does not provide a hell for people to choose in the end, then it seems to me that God is no better than a husband who locks his wife in a basement and forces her to be with Him. If there is no hell, as awful as that might be, then there is no way for people to choose to love and be with God; because in the end that is what we will all be forced to do whether we like it or not.
That being said, I think that much harm has been done by the church’s use of hell as a weapon or a tool of manipulation against those who do not believe. We should not be going around and scaring people into the Reign of God or passing judgment on who we believe will go to heaven and who won’t. We should be witnessing to the love of God that invites people to make a choice for God and to reciprocate that love.
The one other thing that I will say about this is that to be consistent someone who says that there is no hell must also be clear that there is no heaven either. That’s not what I believe. I believe that there is a heaven and there is a hell, though I don’t claim to fully understand what either of those will be like.
But it seems to me that if one is going to claim that there is no hell, that it is based on archaic imagery from an ancient worldview or that it is nothing more than a metaphor, then one also must say the same thing about heaven because scripturally they go hand in hand. I don’t see how you can argue that hell doesn’t exist without that same logic or scriptural interpretation also discounting the existence of heaven.
While I hear many voices calling us to throw out the idea of hell, I don’t hear many people, even those without faith, who are willing to also discount the existence of heaven. That disconnect raises red flags in my mind that the arguments against hell may be based more on personal preference and comfort than they are on scriptural interpretation.
Conclusion: To experience and extend
And so as we conclude this article and this series, we must consider what all of this means for us and for our faith. We must individually discern what it is that God is calling us to build upon this foundation and we must congregationally consider what it is that God intends to grow in this fertile soil.
Ultimately when we come to the article on the Reign of God, it seems to me that we are invited to take seriously both the future and the present realities of that. It seems to me that we are faced with considering judgment and grace and heaven and hell. And in considering these realities we are faced with the invitation to do something about our faith not only for ourselves but also for the world around us.
Our congregational purpose statement is “to experience and extend the gracious rule of God.” It seems to me that our Confession of Faith as a whole and our final article in particular invite us to experience God’s love and to choose Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior of our lives. Moreover, it seems to me that this article and the whole of our confession invite us to extend that love and the invitation to faith to all that we encounter through living out the Reign of God in our midst. May God empower us to do so on God’s behalf.
Amen.