Song of Songs and
Ecclesiastes: Solomon’s Passions and Pangs
June 7, 2015
BMC- Song of Songs 4:8-10, 8:6-7 & Ecclesiastes
1:12-2:11
Through the Bible in a Year
Introduction: Waffle House
Well we got back from our family
vacation to Florida and Disney World Thursday afternoon. We had a great time. The camper we borrowed didn’t give us any major
problems. The van, which we had repaired
before leaving, ran well for us. And the
weather was very good overall with only a few rain showers and some hot
afternoons.
We spent Memorial Day packing and
getting the house ready to be away for awhile.
We hitched up the camper and went to a graduation party that evening
before heading out of town Monday night.
With the age of our kids and their propensity for frequent potty breaks,
we opted to drive through the night. Our
goal was to get south of Atlanta before rush hour traffic began. And this ended up working very well.
We made minimal stops during the
night and arrived at a state camp ground south of Atlanta around 7:30am Tuesday
morning. We ate breakfast which we had
brought along; and when the campground office opened at 8, we took a chance and
asked if we could check in early. We were
blessed to learn that no one had stayed in our campsite the night before. This meant that we were able to move into it
right away instead of having to wait until the afternoon to do so.
Now we knew that we were going to
be exhausted from driving all night and that we would not want to set-up the
pop-up camper only to have to take it down the following morning. We also knew that there was a good chance of
rain Tuesday afternoon. Plus we thought
it would be fun to do something a little different so we reserved a yurt for
the night. Anyone know what a yurt is?
{pause}
According to dictionary.com, a yurt
is “a tentlike
dwelling of the Mongol and Turkic peoples of central Asia, consisting of a cylindrical wall of poles in a lattice arrangement with a conical roof of poles, both covered by felt or skins.” And it looks like this.
Well, I rested for a bit while Beth
watched the kids. We had lunch that we
had brought along and then Beth rested while I watched the kids. The kids had hoped to go swimming; but as
expected, it started to rain. I was glad
we hadn’t set the camper up for the night since we would have needed to put it
down wet the next morning if we had. With
outdoor activities eliminated by the rain, we went with plan B. We went into town to watch a movie.
We found a theatre that was showing
Tomorrowland which seemed rather fitting since we were on our way to
Disney World and a visit to Tomorrowland.
We killed some time at a Barnes and Noble bookstore, watched the movie
and then went out for supper. It turns
out that my children had never eaten at a Waffle House before; and since we
were in the south, I thought it only right that we expand their horizons a bit.
And though I think that they may
have been a bit leery at first, in the end they came to appreciate the choice. That didn’t surprise me though. What surprised me was who I was mistaken for while
in the restaurant. And that confusion
brings us to our passages for this morning because there tends to be a fair
amount of confusion surrounding these books of the Bible, doesn’t there?
Solomon
You’ll
remember that a few weeks ago we reflected on the scandal of Solomon. For all of the wisdom that he had, he still
blew it when it came to remaining true to the Lord. He did not follow the Lord’s teachings and he
married a variety of women from a plethora of places with a gamut of gods. Through these marriages to 700 noble women
and 300 concubines, he was led astray.
He worshiped gods other than the LORD.
Then two
weeks ago, we reflected on a sampling of Solomon’s wisdom that he recorded for
us in Proverbs. This was wisdom that is
passed down from parent to child, internalized on our hearts, and that reminds
us to trust in the Lord rather than ourselves in leading our direction. Ironically, perhaps that was a portion of
Solomon’s downfall. Perhaps in part,
Solomon relied too heavily on his own wisdom rather than that of God especially
for direction.
At any
rate, we know that Solomon asked God for wisdom and that God granted this and
more. We know that Solomon was known for
his wisdom. He was able to discern the
true mother of the infant and the Queen of Sheba came to bask in his wisdom. Solomon was wise and beyond writing a couple
of Psalms and a slew of Proverbs, he is credited with writing Song of Songs and
Ecclesiastes.
Solomon’s Passions
Now let’s be honest here. Many of us are rather uncomfortable with
reading Song of Songs. Some of us may
even wonder if it should really be included in the Bible at all. We may feel a little uneasy or embarrassed to
be reading it at all let alone in public during a worship service.
I still remember as a late
elementary or early middle school boy going to my room to read the Bible and
closing the door before I read Song of Songs.
Somehow, even though it was the Bible that I was reading; it still felt
a bit like I was reading something that I shouldn’t be. And in choosing my passage for this morning,
I was intentional about choosing a G rated section.
We wonder what we are to do with
these verses. What do they mean for us
today? Are they about a healthy marital
relationship with our spouse? Well that
is certainly present here and we could spend time flushing that out. Or are these verses a figurative description
of our relationship to God? After all
there are many passages in the Bible that compare God’s love for us with that of
a spouse, so that is certainly possible as well.
And yet within those good and important
meanings, I am struck by a great irony here.
These words were written by King Solomon and given what we know of King
Solomon, I wonder if what we have here is also a window into Solomon’s
passions. Because if this is about the
beauty and the intimacy that is possible when we give our love wholly to one
individual we have a bit of a disconnect here don’t we?
For instance in chapter 4, we read
of Solomon’s devotion to his bride. We
read of how she had stolen his heart. We
read that her love was better than wine.
Solomon was clearly taken with this woman.
And then in chapter 8, we read of
her devotion to him in return. “Place me like a seal over your heart, like a seal on your arm; for
love is as strong as death, its jealousy unyielding as the grave. It burns like
blazing fire, like a mighty flame. Many waters cannot quench
love; rivers
cannot sweep it away. If one were to give all the wealth of one’s house for
love, it would
be utterly scorned.” She is committed to
him and she is naming the power of that love.
We have here beautiful imagery for the potential in love of intimacy and
commitment.
Yet we know that
in the midst of this passion that Solomon expressed and the depth of love that
she has named in return that Solomon did not remain solely faithful to
her. In fact, he was not even content
with two wives. Instead, he took on 700
wives and 300 concubines. And so if this
is a message about love and faithfulness, this is also an example of mistaken
identity because Solomon certainly did not live this out. Instead of living into the passion that he
had for this one woman that could have developed into a deeply intimate
relationship, he took the passion that he expressed here and sought to
experience it with as many women as he could.
He misunderstood the passion that he felt.
And if this is
primarily an allegory for our relationship to our God, Solomon still fared no
better, did he? If this description of
the love of a man for a woman is to represent the love of God for us and her
devotion in return is to represent our faithfulness to God, Solomon did not
live this out either. This too was a
case of mistaken identity. In taking on
all of those wives, he also took on all of their gods. He did not remain faithful to the LORD, but
rather worshiped many gods. He took the
passion that he experienced for the LORD and sought to experience it with as
many gods as he could. Rather than going
deeper with his God, Solomon sought to experience passion with more gods.
Solomon’s Pangs
All of this brings us to the book
of Ecclesiastes. And once again, we
struggle to know what to do with these words.
We are assaulted by the thought that all that we do is meaningless when
so many of us strive to have meaning and purpose in our lives. We desire to create a legacy, to make an
impact.
Yet some scholars speculate that
Solomon wrote these words toward the end of his life. And as we heard read, Solomon, the Teacher,
had come to see that all of his wisdom and his pursuit of knowledge was
meaningless. He sought pleasure through
laughter and wine but found that to be meaningless. He took to building things like houses,
vineyards, gardens and parks but that was meaningless as well. Solomon amassed wealth including slaves,
silver, and gold; but all of this was meaningless too. And finally he built a harem of women,
seeking meaning in the pleasures of intimacy between a man and woman, thinking
that more was better. He lived into his
passions but as we read Ecclesiastes, we discover only his pangs.
He declared, “I denied
myself nothing my eyes desired; I refused my heart no pleasure.
My heart took delight in all my labor, and this was the reward for
all my toil. Yet when I surveyed all that my hands had done and what I had toiled to
achieve, everything was meaningless, a chasing after the wind; nothing was
gained under the sun.” The more he
grasped for meaning through his passions, the less meaning he found. And isn’t this true of so much of our culture
today as well?
So many of us at
one time or another chase after this pleasure, or that success, or this wealth,
or that accomplishment believing deeply that it will bring us meaning,
believing that on the other side we will find happiness. Yet in the words of Solomon, the wise, we
learn that for all of his wisdom these pursuits of his passions only led him to
pangs. For all of his wisdom, Solomon
misidentified what was most important in life.
Solomon identified more with meaning, when instead he should have sought
depth to find meaning.
Mistaken Identity
Of course, this brings me back to
that night of our vacation in which we ate at the Waffle House south of Atlanta
and I experienced a case of mistaken identity.
Now the restaurant was not very busy.
In fact we were the only customers there at the time. We placed our orders and as we sat there
waiting for our food, the cook came out and looked at me and then went to
whisper something to the waitress.
It turns out that at first glance
he had mistaken me for someone else. He
had mistaken me for a celebrity. Any guesses
who he thought that I was? {Pause} Well, he confused me with this guy. Anyone know who this is? {pause} Yeah, me
neither. But maybe this picture will
help. Anyone? {Pause} Well, I had never
heard of him before because I don’t watch professional wrestling. But it turns out that at first glance, the
cook thought that I was a wrestler called “The Big Show.” Thankfully it was not hard to convince them
otherwise, though. But all this has me
thinking about Solomon’s mistaken approach to meaning.
Conclusion: Broken Together
Just as there was confusion about
my identity in the Waffle House, there has been a lot of confusion over the
meaning behind the Song of Songs and Ecclesiastes. What are we to do with these books? In fact, there is so much controversy about
the context for understanding these that when Ted and Lee performed a drama
about Song of Songs, King Solomon’s closing line was “I just hope that nobody
takes this out of context.”
But perhaps ironically, the
confusion was really on the part of Solomon.
There is deep truth in what Solomon had to say and yet, we have already
seen that despite all of Solomon’s wisdom he still didn’t always get it. In
reading the Song of Songs, we read of Solomon’s passion for the love of a
woman. We have the sense that he threw
himself fully into this believing that it would bring him satisfaction and
meaning, believing that love was all that he really needed. Yet he missed how to achieve the depth of the
love that he sought. Instead of pouring
all of that love into one woman and loving her alone for all of who she was, he
took on 999 other woman as well. If the
love of one woman is this good, how much more would the love of another 999 be,
right? Wrong. Solomon went for quantity of relationship
rather than depth of relationship.
And perhaps we see a glimpse of
this within his depression that is expressed throughout the book of
Ecclesiastes. At the end of his life, he
had come to see that all that he had striven for was not as fulfilling as he
once thought it would be. In fact he
reached a point in which it all seemed so meaningless to him. But perhaps this was in part because he had
not paid enough attention to his own words.
Solomon told us in Ecclesiastes
4:8 that being alone is meaningless. And
he suggested in the following verses that having someone else to care for us in
times of weakness and to keep us warm in times of cold is so much better. Yet he did not remain true to this. He certainly did not remain with one
wife. And he clearly did not remain with
one god. He believed that more was
better when in the case of relationships, deeper is actually better than more
isn’t it? That is where meaning is often
found.
At least, that is what Beth and I
have found in our 15 years of marriage.
And I believe that this is also true for many people in a friendship and
certainly in our relationship with God.
But the struggle is often that to live into this whether it be in a
marriage, a friendship or in our relationship with God, we must come to terms
with the reality that as we go deeper, we also see one another’s and our own
brokenness which is what I appreciate so much about Casting Crowns song,
“Broken Together.” Take a listen.
“Maybe you and I were never meant
to be complete. Could we just be broken
together? If you can bring your
shattered dreams and I’ll bring mine, could healing still be spoken and save
us? The only way we’ll last forever is
broken together.”
So often we have an idealized view
of what will make us happy, what will make us complete, what will bring us
meaning. And I suppose that there are a
variety of possibilities for this, but it seems to me that from Solomon’s
words, we learn that it is not the fulfillment of our passions that bring us
meaning. Fulfilling our passions only
bring us pangs. But I wonder if rather
than seeking what we don’t have to bring meaning, we should be bringing what we
do have; our brokenness, into our relationships with one another and with the
God that we serve. And that as we go
deeper instead of going broader if we can find the meaning that eluded the
wisdom of Solomon. May God guide us in
this journey.
Amen.
No comments:
Post a Comment